Monterey Bay
Columbus Crew IIMonterey Bay
El Paso Locomotive1–0Monterey BayColumbus Crew II3–2Atlanta United II
FC Cincinnati II0–1Columbus Crew IIColumbus Crew II2–1Connecticut FC
New York City II2–3Columbus Crew IIColumbus Crew II2–2Toronto II
Philadelphia Union II1–1Columbus Crew IIFC Cincinnati II2–1Columbus Crew II
New York RB II4–1Columbus Crew IIColumbus Crew II2–1New England II
Connecticut FC1–3Columbus Crew II
Chattanooga2–0Columbus Crew IIColumbus Crew II2–0FC Cincinnati IIColumbus Crew II3–2Toronto IIColumbus Crew II0–0New York City IINew York RB II4–2Columbus Crew II
